On City Water Hill – Theatre Upstairs – Review

On City Water HillOn City Water Hill by Philip St John

For his third play, St. John opts for a two hander using two men who arrange to meet at a remote, mountainous location in the vicinity of Dublin. Frank (Pat Nolan) needs the specialist services of Gary (Neil Fleming) following the break up of his marriage by a 6ft 3in lawyer from Jamaica. Even though the piece is just under an hour in duration there are three specific acts as the story spreads out over a period of time.

The specialist services which Gary can arrange are not for those who believe in the rule of law… think serious organised crime. However Frank wants his victim to survive in order to suffer, so he has worked out a refinement about which even Gary (“I am a stranger to scruples”) has initial doubts. His momentary uncertainty place Frank in the ascendant in the power play between them.

St John has the ability to create some appropriate phrases in the dialogue such as “chronic emotional illiteracy” and uses a mundane, simple final sentence to provide an effective end, leaving the audience in no doubt as to what will occur when the lights go out.

After a somewhat shaky start, the play settled into a grim power exchange between the two men as each of their own certainties waxed and waned. However the man of experience, Gary, is the one who understands the world; he is contemplative, he reads. Frank’s foundations, even if he has enjoyed a certain amount of transitory commercial success as a film producer, are less knowing, less sure footed. He is an innocent abroad.

St John has created a well-crafted play about the dark world of criminal contracts which kept me, I cannot say happily occupied given the subject matter, engaged in a world which is beyond my ken even though our news contains much evidence that it is alive and well and living in Dublin.

Review by Frank L

On City Water Hill runs from May 6th – 17th @ Theatre Upstairs

Neill Fleming as Gary

Pat Nolan as Frank

Director / Liam Halligan

Set Design / Laura Kelly

Design Consultant / Marcus Costello

Producer / Anna Wolf
DATES: Tuesday, May 6th – Saturday, May 17th

1PM Performances:

Tuesday – Saturday
(May 6th – 10th / May 13th – 17th)

7PM Performances:

Thursday – Saturday
(May 8th – 10th / May 15th – 17th)



3 replies »

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.