The Argument of Us – The New Theatre – Review

The New Theatre presents THE ARGUMENT OF US by Colm Maher.
Dates: 19/05/2026 – 30/05/2026

We meet a couple in unusual circumstances. Rhys (Gemma Allan) has returned to their apartment after seven weeks of complete silence. The pair have lived together for many years, but one night she left without warning and never came back. During their time apart, they had no contact whatsoever. As Rhys starts talking to Bishop (Darren Mone) again, a palpable nervous energy hangs in the air.

This is a new work by writer Colm Maher. If you have attended Bewley’s Cafe Theatre, you may already know Maher from his role as front of house (Venue and Technical Manager) at the long-running lunchtime theatre. This piece is directed by Iseult Golden, who is also closely associated with Bewley’s (Administrator and Producer).

The play is a two-hander, following the young couple as they attempt to unravel the reasons their relationship slowly fell apart, and whether any hope of reconciliation still remains. Their conversation moves through a series of memories, incidents, and unresolved tensions from their shared past, while they drink miniature bottles of spirits collected during trips to various destinations around the world.

The set is simple but effective. Six paintings on the back wall depict a starscape, with the imagery spilling dramatically onto the floor. A glass coffee table littered with empty cans and bottles hints at Bishop’s activities the previous night and adds to the sense of emotional disarray.

At its heart, the play is a portrait of a relationship under strain. Over the course of the piece, we learn more about both individuals and the gradual erosion of their connection. While it is impossible to fully distil the complexities of two intertwined lives into a short work, the play succeeds in offering observations, anecdotes, and revealing glimpses into the fragile dynamics of a long-term relationship. The piece is intense, but could do with more levity to lighten the mood.

By the end, the audience is left reflecting on how easily distance can grow between two people, even when love still lingers beneath the surface. The play does not offer easy answers, but instead presents a raw and honest exploration of communication, regret, and the difficult possibility of beginning again.

Cast and Crew – 

Directed by Iseult Golden

Starring Gemma Allan and Darren Mone.

Lighting Design – Cathy O’Carroll

Set Design & Construction – Martin Cahill

Stage Management – Eva Walsh

Photography – Al Craig